On 21 March 2001 the web edition of the New York Times reported that telephone operators in India are pretending to be from Perth Amboy. Will the wonders of globalization never cease?

Hi, I'm in Bangalore (but I Dare Not Tell)

by MARK LANDLER


BANGALORE, India, March 15 — With frosted glass and funky amber
lights playing off the turquoise walls, the offices of Customer
Asset look more like a Santa Fe diner than a telephone call center
in southern India. The cultural vertigo is complete when employees
introduce themselves to a visitor.

 "Hi, my name is Susan Sanders, and I'm from Chicago," said C. R.
Suman, 22, who is in fact a native of Bangalore and fields calls
from customers of a telecommunications company in the United
States.

 Ms. Suman's fluent English and broad vowels would pass muster in
the stands at Wrigley Field. In case her callers ask personal
questions, Ms. Suman has conjured up a fictional American life,
with parents Bob and Ann, brother Mark and a made-up business
degree from the University of Illinois.

 "We watch a lot of `Friends' and `Ally McBeal' to learn the right
phrases," Ms. Suman said. "When people talk about their Bimmer, you
have to know they mean a BMW."

 "Or when they say `No way, José,' there is no José," added Ms.
Suman's co-worker, Nishara Anthony, who goes by the name Naomi
Morrison and, if asked, says she comes from Perth Amboy, N.J.

 The point of this pretense is to convince Americans who dial toll-
free numbers that the person on the other end of the line works
right nearby — not 8,300 miles away, in a country where static-
free calls used to be a novelty.

 Call centers are a booming business in India, as companies like
General Electric and British Airways set up supermarket-size phone
banks to handle a daily barrage of customer inquiries. The
companies value India for its widespread use of English and
low-cost labor. 

 But call centers are only the low end of a much larger industry of
Indian software developers, transcribers, accountants, Web site
designers and animation artists who work on projects for foreign
companies from Indian offices. By 2008, such assignments will
generate 800,000 new jobs and $17 billion in revenue for India,
according to the consultants McKinsey & Company.

 "India is on its way to being the back office for the world," said
Shriram Ramdas, one of the founders of Bangalore Labs, which
manages Web sites and other information networks for companies from
a futuristic office in the International Tech Park on the outskirts
of Bangalore.

 Doing back-office chores for advanced economies may not sound
glamorous, especially for a nation that has created an $8 billion
computer software industry virtually from scratch in the last
decade. But it could spread the wealth of India's technology
revolution beyond the pockets of prosperity that exist today in
Bangalore, Hyderabad and a few other hubs of high technology.

 "Right now, when you come to our campus, you're leaving India
behind," said N. R. Narayana Murthy, the chairman of Infosys
Technologies, one of India's most successful software companies and
the first to be listed on Nasdaq. "We're living in a make-believe
world."

 With its putting green, aerobics studio, basketball court and even
a deer park, the Infosys headquarters is a powerful symbol of what
technology has brought to India since the late 1980's. Companies
like Infosys and the rival Wipro Ltd. are deeply embedded in the
microchips of dozens of the largest American businesses.

 Unlike Taiwan or South Korea, which became known as low-cost
producers of computer hardware, India made its name as an
unparalleled customer service agent. While their American clients
sleep, software writers churn out code, which is then beamed by
satellite to the United States.

 These services became so valuable that the founders of Infosys and
Wipro were able to take their companies public at dot-com-like
valuations. Mr. Murthy became a billionaire, and stock options
showered unheard-of riches on even low-level employees. The man who
serves tea to Mr. Murthy recently cashed in his options to buy a
$100,000 house. His driver bought his own car.

 About 2.8 million people work in India's technology industry, even
with a steady exodus of top software developers to Silicon Valley
or suburban Boston. Yet the industry, despite its breakneck growth,
still accounts for only 2 percent of India's total economic output
of $450 billion.

 For all the talk about the Indian technology revolution, the
technology industry has made only a glancing impression on the
physical landscape of the country. Bangalore is ringed by
technology parks that could be in Palo Alto or Austin. But the city
itself is a mess, with potholed roads, crumbling buildings and a
ramshackle, overburdened airport with no international flights.

 For technology to make a dent in the pervasive poverty of this
country, Mr. Murthy contends, it must account for 10 percent of
India's gross domestic product. At current growth rates, India will
have a $900 billion economy in 2010; technology would then have to
be a $90 billion industry. "We need to broaden the base of
technology in India," Mr. Murthy said. "This new business will be
very valuable as a way to generate jobs for people who are not as
skilled as software programmers."

 Although back-office work is not particularly challenging for a
company like Infosys, Mr. Murthy said he would consider expanding
into it, if only to create thousands of more jobs in Bangalore.

 Jobs in call centers are coveted here. While the salaries are
hardly lucrative by technology industry standards — anywhere from
$1,600 to $2,100 a year — they beat those for most clerical
positions.

 "In the U.S., these jobs are taken by housewives or kids who
haven't decided what they want to do with their lives," said K.
Ghanesh, 39, the founder of Customer Asset. "Here, they are career
jobs for college graduates."

 The back-office business may help cushion India from the economic
slowdown in the United States. As companies cut their spending on
new computer systems, Indian software producers are likely to feel
the pinch.

 But routine work, like processing insurance claims or settling
credit card bills, goes on no matter what the economic climate.
Indeed, as companies look for ways to cut costs, more of them may
send such work to India, where wages often run half those in the
United States.

 Sending jobs abroad in uncertain times does not bring good
publicity to American companies. None of the foreign clients of
Customer Asset permit the company to disclose their names, and the
offices are scrupulously bare of any reference to non- Indian
clients. A spokesman said only that Ms. Anthony and Ms. Suman serve
a telecommunications company based in the United States.

 It would not be the first time that America's misery is India's
opportunity.

 Ashok Soota, a prominent technology executive who recently started
his own software consulting firm, noted that India's
high-technology industry was born in 1991, a recession year, when
American companies first looked overseas for skilled, but cheap,
programmers to update their computer systems.

 "This slowdown will force us to explore new markets," Mr. Soota
said. "But this time, there is another factor — bandwidth."

 In the last two years, India has installed reliable high-capacity
telephone lines in most of its major cities. That makes it possible
for people in this country to communicate with customers in the
United States, by phone or over the Internet, with no discernible
difference from a calling center in Nebraska.

 The improved telephone network has essentially erased the
advantage of other countries that offer back- office services —
notably Ireland, one of the growth leaders of the expensive new
Europe.

 India's greatest strength in this business may prove to be its
ability to adapt, chameleon-like, to its customers. For a decade,
Infosys, Wipro and others have run development centers in the
United States to reduce the anxiety of American companies in
dealing with foreigners.

 Now, companies here are blurring the line between India and the
United States further. Mr. Ramdas of Bangalore Labs plans to
relocate to Northern California so he can live among his customers.
Mr. Soota's partner, Subroto Bagchi, also plans to move, to North
Jersey, in two months.

 "We see ourselves as a next-generation company that is neither
Indian nor American," Mr. Bagchi said.

 In recent years, the best engineers and programmers left India for
the United States. But as India's industry has matured, émigrés are
returning home to apply the lessons of the American market in local
companies. In some cases, they bring home the culture as well.

 At Customer Asset and other call centers, Indian trainers who have
lived in the United States drill new employees in phonetics,
American pop culture and colloquialisms.

 "If you're hiring people for Citibank," said Gayatri Balaji, vice
president for client services, "you want them to know that bulls
and bears are not just different animals found in nature."

 The regimen includes listening to the likes of "Friends" and "Ally
McBeal" without the picture, and then reconstructing the dialogue.
The new recruits are put through role-playing sessions in which the
trainer, posing as a caller, interrogates them on American movies,
sports and television programs.

 At Customer Asset, employees are allowed to fashion their own
telephone aliases and identities. Ms. Anthony chose "Naomi
Morrison" because, she said, she has the same skin tone as the
model Naomi Campbell and is a fan of the late Jim Morrison.

 "If I gave people my Indian name, it would be too confusing," said
Ms. Anthony, a 26-year-old from Cochin, a coastal city. "The whole
intention is for them to understand us, and us to understand them."

 And what happens if a caller asks too many questions?

 "When the conversation goes too deeply into Chicago," Ms. Suman said, 
"you just ask politely, `Can we get back to business?' "   

http://www.nytimes.com/2001/03/21/technology/21CALL.html?ex=986197325&ei=1&en=f592e7971e9539fc

For general information about NYTimes.com, write to help@nytimes.com.

Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company

Return to Joe Strzalka's Perth Amboy tribute page.

Return to Joe Strzalka's home page.


Perth Amboy in India / April 2001 / send comments to strzalka@sas.upenn.edu